The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →The best roasting pan depends on what you cook and how you use it afterward. For a versatile stainless-steel pan, The Kitchn’s pick is the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16-inch; for a lighter value option, Reviewed favors the Circulon 56539; for a nonstick pan, The Kitchn selects Caraway; and for a premium stainless alternative, Reviewed recommends Viking’s 3-Ply model. These are distinct picks from published reviews, not a single head-to-head test of all four.
Our four roasting-pan picks
| Best for | Pan | What the cited review found | Trade-off to consider |
|---|---|---|---|
| Versatile stainless steel | Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16-inch roasting pan with rack | The Kitchn named it overall, citing sturdy construction, even cooking, wide handles, a flat bottom and a well-shaped rack. Reviewed also recommended the Cuisinart MCP117-16BR, noting its flat surface and easy-to-lift rack handles. | Reviewed said the handles could allow more room. Confirm the exact model and dimensions before buying. |
| Lighter value option | Circulon 56539 Roaster with U-Rack | Reviewed named it its value pick. Its test found good searing, a well-cooked chicken, easy cleaning and a rack that held a 20-pound turkey securely. The reviewer reported a weight of 6.55 pounds. | Reviewed cautioned that the nonstick finish may not last a lifetime. That reported weight and turkey result belong to the tested product, not every current listing or revision. |
| Nonstick | Caraway Roasting Pan | The Kitchn’s nonstick pick, reported to cook evenly and clean easily in its review. | The Kitchn reported a nine-pound pan and a low-sitting U-shaped rack; it also cautioned against metal utensils on the coating. |
| Premium stainless alternative | Viking 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack | Reviewed named it overall after oven and stovetop tests, praising heat distribution, comfortable handles, sturdiness and cleanup. | Reviewed described it as hefty. The rack is nonstick, so follow its current care and heat guidance. |
These recommendations synthesize reviews with different test methods and dates. Prices and stock change; no current price is quoted here. Check the manufacturer’s care instructions and the exact model listing before purchase.
How to choose a roasting pan
How big should your roasting pan be?
Start with the oven, then the food. A pan must fit your oven with enough clearance to slide in and out safely, and its interior should accommodate the roast without crowding vegetables or obstructing heat circulation. Food Network’s buying guidance treats size and weight as practical selection factors; Epicurious likewise emphasizes rack clearance and construction. Check the pan’s interior dimensions, not just its advertised length, and compare them with your oven rack and the food you cook most often.
A dedicated pan is most useful for large poultry and roasts. For smaller everyday cuts, a skillet may be sufficient, as Food Network and Epicurious note in their buying guidance.
#1 Best Overall
- EXCEPTIONAL DESIGN: The Cuisinart 16-inch rectangular roaster is made with a high-performance stainless steel exterior and riveted stainless steel handles. The steel rack is large enough to handle a big Thanksgiving turkey and perfect for slow-roasting root vegetables
- STURDY & STRONG: A sturdy rack with stainless steel handles allows elevated cooking exposure for fat to drain off of food and makes removing items easy
- MEASUREMENTS: Pan measurements: 16.8” Length, 12.8” Width, 3.4” High. Handles with rack measurement: 21.1” Length, 12.8” Width, 5.8” High
- WARRANTY: Lifetime warranty
What kind of material do you want in a roasting pan?
Multi-ply stainless steel with an aluminum core is a common choice in the cited reviews because it combines heat distribution with a surface suited to stovetop cooking. The Kitchn describes the Cuisinart’s aluminum core surrounded by stainless steel; Reviewed praised heat distribution in the Viking. These are findings about specific tested pans, not a guarantee that every stainless pan performs alike.
Nonstick models can simplify food release and cleanup, but coating care, utensil restrictions and heat limits vary by product. Carbon steel can also be a capable value choice: Reviewed’s test included nonstick and stainless pans and found its Circulon pick performed well. Match the material to your cooking and cleanup preferences rather than assuming one construction is best for every use.
Rank #2
- VERSATILE ROASTING PAN – A cookware essential. This big 15 inch roaster is ideal for cooking turkey, chicken or beef, along with other meats and vegetables.
- PREMIUM NONSTICK BAKEWARE – Durable nonstick coating makes kitchen cleanup a breeze – and it’s even dishwasher safe!
- LARGE METAL RACK FOR EVEN BAKING – V-shaped iron rack offers increased airflow for consistently delicious results.
- HEAVY DUTY STEEL CONSTRUCTION – Durable and warp-resistant, this set withstands oven temperatures up to 464 degrees Fahrenheit (240 degrees Celsius).
- DEEP RECTANGULAR CASSEROLE DISH – At 15 x 10.3 x 2.8 inches (excluding handles) this roasting pan is perfectly sized for holidays, dinner parties, potlucks and hearty weekday meals.
Check the rack, handles and base
- Rack shape and clearance: A V-shaped rack can help stabilize poultry. Food Network’s reviewers caution that a U-shaped rack may leave less space beneath the roast for vegetables or drippings. Check how securely a rack sits and whether you can lift it when loaded.
- Handles: A large roast makes the loaded pan substantially harder to manage than an empty one. Look for handles you can grip securely with oven mitts and enough clearance from the pan body.
- Flatness and stovetop use: A flat base matters if you want to make gravy or sear in the pan. Reviewed found flat-bottomed pans easier for gravy and stovetop work; a raised center can affect where oil collects.
- Cleaning: Consider whether the pan and rack are easy to clean and whether the manufacturer permits dishwasher use. Do not assume a nonstick finish or rack is safe for every utensil, temperature or cleaning method.
What the published tests actually covered
The picks above come from separate reviews, not one standardized competition. The Kitchn’s November 9, 2025 update says it tested five pans by roasting a 4-to-6-pound chicken over two pounds of vegetables, assessing browning, moisture, cooking time, vegetable fit and browning, then making gravy across two gas burners. It named the Cuisinart overall, Farberware’s 12-by-16-inch nonstick roaster its budget pick, and Caraway its nonstick pick. Read The Kitchn’s roasting-pan review.
Food Network’s review, titled for 2026, says its process considered size, weight, use and care information before washing and cooking with pans. Its guidance also discusses rack and handle trade-offs. Read Food Network’s roasting-pan review.
Rank #3
- MULTI-USE SIZE FOR ROASTING & BREAD BAKING: 13-inch oval roaster fits up to 7 lb poultry or roast and doubles as an ideal vessel for baking sourdough bread. The enclosed design traps steam for crispy crusts and artisan-style results at home.
- SUPERIOR HEAT PERFORMANCE: Porcelain enamel on steel absorbs and distributes heat evenly for consistent cooking. Oven safe up to 932°F—perfect for high-heat sourdough baking, roasting meats, or baking casseroles.
- SELF-BASTING LID FOR MOISTURE & CRUST DEVELOPMENT: Tight-fitting lid retains moisture while roasting and creates a steamy environment ideal for sourdough bread baking—helping achieve a golden crust and soft interior.
- DISHWASHER SAFE & EASY RELEASE: Smooth glass-like surface resists sticking and makes cleanup simple. Ideal for everyday use, from artisan bread baking to weeknight meals.
- CHEMICAL-FREE & BUILT TO LAST: PFOA and PTFE-free construction ensures safe cooking. Durable enameled steel won’t absorb flavors, making it perfect for switching between savory roasts and sourdough baking without flavor transfer.
Reviewed says it tested ten roasting pans, roasting chicken and pork loin over vegetables, making gravy across two burners, searing pork, and evaluating cleanup, handles, rack movement and pouring. It selected Viking overall and Circulon for value. The opened page does not establish a publication or update year, so its results should not be presented as a verified 2026 test. Read Reviewed’s roasting-pan test.
Epicurious’s November 2024 review says it tested 11 models, including nonstick, stainless steel, aluminum and ceramic pans. Its overall pick was the Anolon Triply Clad Stainless Steel Roaster with Nonstick Rack; the review reports crisp vegetable browning and easy cleanup, but also says it was the heaviest tested, at over 10.5 pounds, and has a 500°F oven limit with no broiler use because of the nonstick rack. The review reports the rack held a 20-pound turkey; verify current product details before treating that as a current specification. Read Epicurious’s roasting-pan review.
Rank #4
- SUPERIOR COOKING FOR YEARS TO COME: Heavy-duty steel roaster pan designed to resist warping for years of roasting performance
- ELEVATED COOKING EXPERIENCE: Roast pan features a removable chrome-plated rack which raises meats up to allow fats to drip away
- THOUGHTFULLY DESIGNED: Responsibly made without PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium. Product design does not involve intentionally adding to the interior nonstick coating any of these substances which may otherwise be present in the environment
- STURDY, EASY TO GRIP HANDLES: Wide, dual-riveted cast stainless steel handles on this turkey roasting pan make it easier to remove from the oven, while wide handles on the chrome-plated rack aid in removing roasts, seafood and more
- QUALITY ASSURANCE GUARANTEE: Farberware baking pans for oven offer nonstick cooking with easy cleanup
As Beth Lipton and Kendra Vaculin put it in that November 14, 2024 Epicurious article, “The good news is that with roasting pans, it’s hard to go wrong.” That is their editorial assessment, not a controlled-test finding. Their review’s Anolon recommendation differs from the other picks here because the publications tested different pans using different protocols and chose for different priorities.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- SIZE - 16L x 12W x 6H inch and inside dimensions 15L x 10.5W x 3.5H inch.
- HEAVY DUTY CONSTRUCTION - Carbon Steel Turkey Roaster features a spacious and thermally efficient design that's perfect for roasting or braising large poultry or meat.Suitable for heating appliances such as ovens, gas stoves, electric stoves, induction cookers, etc. Not suitable for microwave oven.
- NATURALLY NONSTICK - Roasting pans are carefully crafted with a core of carbon steel, then covered on the inside and outside with a layer of natural enamel.Enameled steel coated interior with signature handles. Oven safe up to 600 degrees. Induction safe.
- EFFORTLESS CLEANUP - After all the cooking and prepping is done, place cookware in the dishwasher for quick and easy cleanup.If you prefer to hand wash, simply wipe down with a paper towel and rinse under warm, soapy water. Wipe dry.
- KEEP THE DELICIOUSNESS - lid prevents heat and moisture from escaping to provide a tender, tasty and juicy result. Sturdy carbon steel loop handles for easy handling.
Other tested pans worth knowing about
- Farberware 12-by-16-inch nonstick roaster: The Kitchn’s budget pick. Its reviewer reported that the heavy-gauge steel pan and rack browned chicken well and cleaned easily. Confirm the current model and coating instructions.
- All-Clad E752C264 large roaster with nonstick rack: Reviewed reported strong oven performance and well-designed handles, but found that its raised center caused oil to pool toward the sides during searing.
- Anolon Triply Clad Stainless Steel Roaster with Nonstick Rack: Epicurious’s November 2024 overall pick. Its test findings and reported heat limit are described above; check current manufacturer guidance before use.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Recommended Free Tools
