For most buyers, the Weber Lumin Electric Grill is the best electric grill overall. Popular Mechanics selected it as the best electric grill in a current tested-grill guide, and its hands-on review found quick heating, strong heat retention with the lid closed, and useful smoking, steaming, warming, and griddle-style capabilities. The Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL is a better choice for maximum versatility, while the Weber Q 1400 is the simpler traditional option for a balcony or patio.
This comparison attributes hands-on findings to the publications that tested the products. Manufacturer pages are used for current specifications, capacities, accessories, and compatibility. Check prices, stock, building rules, and electrical requirements before purchase.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick answer
The Weber Lumin Electric Grill is the best overall choice for most buyers. Popular Mechanics selected it as the best electric grill in a current tested-grill guide, and its hands-on review found that it heats quickly, retains heat well with the lid closed, and does more than grill: compatible inserts support smoking, steaming, warming, and griddle-style cooking. Its main weaknesses are limited cooking area, temperature loss when the lid stays open, and awkward cleaning beneath the heating element.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
The other four grills are better fits for specific jobs: the Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL is the most versatile, the Weber Q 1400 is the best traditional balcony-style grill, the Cuisinart CEG-980 is the most portable, and the George Foreman GFO201R-TX is the simplest large indoor/outdoor option.
#1 Best Overall
- The Black Weber Lumin Grill is a hardworking electric grill with the ability to reach really hot temperatures of over 600°F; allowing you to create high-quality sear marks
- Versatile Settings and Functionality: Sear, smoke, steam or boil with various cook settings; Electric BBQ grill's clearly marked control knob makes it easy to access searing, steaming, smoking, and warming modes
- Grill From Frozen: Steam system thaws frozen foods, like steak and chicken, while your grill preheats; When it's ready, sear on the grilling side for easy weeknight meals
- Keep Warm: Keep your food warm until it's ready to serve, then open the outdoor grill's lid for buffet-style self-service; Low-dome lid design helps cook flatter foods, like steak and fish, efficiently
- Easy Cleaning: Black electric grill has a front-access grease tray that makes removal and clean-up a breeze, allowing you to focus on grilling instead of cleaning
Important evidence note: This is a researched comparison, not a claim that our editorial team personally tested all five grills. Hands-on findings are attributed to the publications that tested them. Manufacturer pages supply the current specifications, capacities, accessories, and compatibility details. Prices, stock, retailer listings, and local-use rules can change.
The five best electric grills at a glance
| Rank | Model | Best for | What stands out | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Weber Lumin Electric Grill | Best overall | Fast heating, heat retention with the lid closed, and grilling, smoking, steaming, warming, and griddle-style capability | Small cooking area; harder to clean under the heating element |
| 2 | Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL | Best multifunction grill | Seven cooking functions, real wood-pellet smoke, app control, and two built-in thermometers | Larger, heavier, and more complicated than a basic grill |
| 3 | Weber Q 1400 Electric Grill | Best traditional balcony grill | 189-square-inch cast-iron grate, infinite heat control, and a durable cast-aluminum body | Grill-first design with fewer functions |
| 4 | Cuisinart Outdoor Electric Grill with VersaStand, CEG-980 | Best compact portable design | Integrated telescoping stand, carrying handle, 145-square-inch grate, and household plug | Official product page showed it out of stock at the time of research |
| 5 | George Foreman Indoor|Outdoor 12+ Serving Rectangular Grill, GFO201R-TX | Best large simple option | 200 square inches of cooking surface, variable temperature control, removable stand, and ceramic nonstick coating | Less refined and less multifunctional than the Weber and Ninja options |
How these grills were ranked
The evidence is not equally strong for every model. The Weber Lumin is the only grill in this five-model list with current, model-specific independent testing that supports the overall-winner position: Popular Mechanics both named it the best electric grill in a tested guide and published a hands-on review.
The Ninja is supported primarily by its official specifications, plus Forbes Vetted’s positioning of the Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL as an upgrade option in an electric-grill roundup. The Weber Q 1400, Cuisinart CEG-980, and George Foreman GFO201R-TX are evaluated mainly from their official product information and intended use cases.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Good Housekeeping adds useful independent context because its Kitchen and Cooking Lab says it has tested more than 30 indoor grills over the past decade and selected George Foreman as a value pick. However, the George Foreman model in that testing is a smaller indoor contact grill, not the rectangular GFO201R-TX reviewed here. Its test result should not be transferred to this exact outdoor model.
1. Weber Lumin Electric Grill: best electric grill overall
Best for: Apartment, condo, balcony, and small-patio users who want the broadest combination of grilling performance and extra cooking modes.
The Lumin is the strongest all-around recommendation because it addresses the main compromise of many electric grills: simplicity. It can function as a conventional grill, but its interchangeable accessories also support smoking, steaming, warming, and griddle-style cooking. Weber’s product materials support those functions, while Popular Mechanics’ hands-on review reports quick heating and strong heat retention from the double-walled enclosure when the lid is closed.
That combination makes the Lumin more useful than a grill that only handles burgers and vegetables. The smoker and griddle-style options are especially relevant if you have limited outdoor space and would rather own one appliance than several specialized cookers. The grill can add smoke flavor without using an open-flame fuel source, but it should not be marketed as a perfect substitute for charcoal. The credible advantage is versatility and smoke capability, not identical charcoal flavor.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →What to watch out for
- Heat with the lid open: Popular Mechanics found that the Lumin has more difficulty maintaining temperature when the lid is open. That matters when you are turning food frequently or cooking a large number of items in batches.
- Cleaning: The area beneath the heating element is difficult to clean, according to the hands-on review. Plan on cleaning around the element carefully rather than treating the grill like a grate and drip tray that can be quickly removed.
- Capacity: It is better suited to smaller households and modest gatherings than to large cookouts.
If you buy it for smoking or flat-top cooking, verify that the insert or accessory you want is compatible with the exact Lumin version. A compatible Weber Lumin grill cover is also worth considering if the grill will remain outdoors, but check the model fit before ordering. Availability and pricing for the grill and accessories should be checked immediately before purchase.
2. Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL: best multifunction electric grill
Best for: Families and hosts who want one outdoor appliance for grilling, smoking, air frying, roasting, baking, broiling, and dehydrating.
The Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL is better understood as an outdoor electric cooking system than as a conventional grill with a cord. Ninja lists seven functions: grill, BBQ smoke, air fry, roast, bake, broil, and dehydrate. It has 180 square inches of cooking space, two built-in thermometers, and app-based monitoring and control for two proteins.
Its distinctive feature is the combination of electrical heat with real wood pellets for smoke flavor. That gives it a different proposition from a basic plug-in grill: you get connected temperature monitoring and several oven-like cooking modes while still having a wood-smoke component. If you regularly cook different foods at different target temperatures, the two-probe setup and app are more meaningful than they would be for someone who only makes burgers.
Rank #2
- HIGH HEAT: Create high-quality sear marks with an electric grill that reaches really hot temperatures over 600°F
- VARIETY: Sear, smoke, steam or boil with various cook settings
- KEEP WARM: Keep food warm until it’s ready to serve. Open the lid for buffet-style self-service.
- FROM FROZEN: Grill from frozen with a steam system that thaws frozen foods, like steak and chicken, while your grill preheats. When it’s ready, sear on the grilling side for easy weeknight meals.
- CONTROL: Clearly marked control knob makes it easy to access searing, steaming, smoking and warming modes.
Why it is not the overall winner
The same features that make the Ninja versatile also make it more appliance-like. It takes more space, has more controls to learn, and is a less obvious choice for someone who simply needs a compact grill for a balcony. It also uses wood pellets, so buyers seeking a nearly smoke-free electric appliance should choose a simpler model instead.
Choose the Ninja when the additional cooking modes and connected monitoring will be used regularly. If those features will sit unused, the Lumin or Q 1400 is likely a more sensible design.
3. Weber Q 1400 Electric Grill: best traditional-style balcony grill
Best for: Balcony and patio users who want a familiar grill format, durable grates, and straightforward controls.
The Q 1400 is the conventional choice in this group. Weber’s U.S. product page lists a 189-square-inch porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grate, a 1,560-watt heating element, a six-foot grounded cord, infinite heat control, a removable catch pan, and a cast-aluminum lid and body.
Recommended Free Tools
That construction gives the Q 1400 a more recognizable grill feel than the multifunction Ninja. The cast-iron grate is the central feature for buyers who care about traditional grill construction, while the removable catch pan makes routine grease management more practical than it would be on a completely fixed design.
Weber specifically positions its electric Q series for balconies, decks, and grilling on the go. That is an intended-use advantage, not a guarantee that every apartment, condominium, HOA, or municipality permits it. Check the rules for your building and the electrical requirements of the installation before buying.
Trade-offs
The Q 1400 is less flexible than the Lumin and far less multifunctional than the Ninja. The available dossier does not include current independent testing that establishes the Q 1400 as a better performer than the Lumin, so its proper distinction is simple traditional construction and balcony-oriented design—not overall superiority.
For repair-minded owners, Weber separately lists a heating element compatible with the Q 140 and Q 1400. Confirm the exact model and part compatibility before ordering a replacement.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute2Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors3Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches4. Cuisinart Outdoor Electric Grill with VersaStand, CEG-980: best compact portable design
Best for: Buyers who need a small grill that can move between tabletop use, storage, and a standing setup.
The CEG-980’s integrated telescoping base is its defining feature. The stand can move between storage, tabletop, and floor-standing configurations, and the grill also has a carrying handle. That makes it a practical candidate for patios, tailgating-style storage, or any situation where a permanent stand would take up too much room.
Cuisinart lists a 145-square-inch grilling area, a 1,500-watt heating element, a porcelain-enameled grate, and a 120-volt household plug. The company says the grill can accommodate up to eight steaks, eight hamburgers, six to 10 chicken breasts, or more than four pounds of fish. Those are manufacturer capacity claims rather than independent test results in this comparison, so treat them as an indication of intended capacity rather than a guarantee of comfortable simultaneous cooking.
Rank #3
- The Ice Blue Weber Lumin Grill is a hardworking electric grill with the ability to reach really hot temperatures of over 600°F, allowing you to create high-quality sear marks
- Versatile Settings and Functionality: Sear, smoke, steam or boil with various cook settings; Electric BBQ grill's clearly marked control knob makes it easy to access searing, steaming, smoking, and warming modes
- Grill From Frozen: Steam system thaws frozen foods, like steak and chicken, while your grill preheats; When it's ready, sear on the grilling side for easy weeknight meals
- Keep Warm: Keep your food warm until it's ready to serve, then open the outdoor grill's lid for buffet-style self-service; Low-dome lid design helps cook flatter foods, like steak and fish, efficiently
- Easy Cleaning: Blue electric grill has a front-access grease tray that makes removal and clean-up a breeze, allowing you to focus on grilling instead of cleaning
Availability warning
The official Cuisinart product page displayed the CEG-980 as out of stock at the time of research. That status can change, but it is important enough to check before recommending this model or planning around it. Confirm a live retailer listing, current price, warranty terms, and the exact model number before purchase.
Windows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallOutdated Drivers Are Slowing You Down
One free scan finds every outdated or missing driver and matches the right update for your exact hardware.Free scan · exact hardware match5. George Foreman Indoor|Outdoor 12+ Serving Rectangular Grill: best large simple option
Best for: Buyers who prioritize a large cooking surface, simple controls, and indoor/outdoor flexibility over premium construction or connected features.
The GFO201R-TX has a 200-square-inch rectangular cooking surface and is rated by George Foreman for more than 12 servings. It includes variable temperature control, a removable stand, a sloped cooking surface, and PFAS-free ceramic nonstick coating.
This is the uncomplicated option. It makes sense for large portions and for shoppers who do not need smoking, app control, multiple cooking modes, or interchangeable inserts. The removable stand also lets the grill adapt to the intended setting rather than requiring a permanent outdoor installation.
Use the indoor/outdoor description carefully. It does not override the product instructions, ventilation requirements, electrical limitations, or building rules for a particular location. Follow the exact manual and confirm that the intended setup is permitted.
Do not confuse the two George Foreman models
Good Housekeeping’s George Foreman value selection comes from testing a smaller indoor contact grill. That testing supports useful value context for the brand, but it is not a direct performance review of the 200-square-inch GFO201R-TX. The specifications and features listed above come from George Foreman’s official page for the rectangular indoor/outdoor model.
Which electric grill should you buy?
| If your priority is… | Choose… | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The best balance of grilling and versatility | Weber Lumin | It combines documented hands-on performance with smoking, steaming, warming, and griddle-style options. |
| The most cooking functions | Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL | It offers seven modes, real wood-pellet smoke, dual thermometers, and app control. |
| A familiar grill for a balcony or patio | Weber Q 1400 | It has a traditional grate-and-lid layout, cast-iron grates, and infinite heat control. |
| Portability and an integrated stand | Cuisinart CEG-980 | The telescoping VersaStand supports tabletop and standing configurations. |
| Large, simple indoor/outdoor cooking | George Foreman GFO201R-TX | It provides 200 square inches, a removable stand, and straightforward variable control. |
What to check before installing or buying an electric grill
1. Building, balcony, and HOA rules
Electric does not automatically mean permitted. Apartment, condominium, rental, balcony, deck, and HOA rules may restrict grills regardless of fuel type. Local requirements can also vary. Check the governing rules for the exact property and intended location before purchase, especially if the grill will be used on a balcony or shared outdoor area.
2. Outlet and cord requirements
Compare the grill’s electrical specifications with the outlet where it will be used. The Weber Q 1400 is listed with a six-foot grounded cord, while Cuisinart lists a 120-volt household plug and 1,500 watts. The Q 1400 is listed at 1,560 watts. These details affect placement and outlet planning; do not assume that any convenient outdoor receptacle is suitable.
Keep the cord routed as directed by the manufacturer, protect connections from conditions the manual excludes, and avoid improvising an installation in a location that was not intended for the appliance. If you are unsure about the outlet or the property’s electrical setup, ask a qualified electrician rather than relying on the grill’s nominal plug type alone.
3. Footprint and cooking area
Cooking-surface numbers are not directly interchangeable with serving claims. The listed areas range from 145 square inches on the Cuisinart to 200 square inches on the George Foreman, while the Ninja lists 180 square inches and the Q 1400 lists 189 square inches. A larger number can help with batch cooking, but the grill’s overall footprint, lid clearance, stand, cord route, and storage position matter just as much in a confined outdoor area.
4. Whether you want smoke or simplicity
The Lumin can smoke with compatible accessories, and the Ninja uses real wood pellets. Those features can add smoke flavor, but they also introduce another part to store and another process to manage. If you want the least complicated grill-only setup, the Q 1400 or George Foreman is a better match.
Rank #4
- The Seafoam Green Weber Lumin Grill is a hardworking electric grill with the ability to reach really hot temperatures of over 600°F, allowing you to create high-quality sear marks
- Versatile Settings and Functionality: Sear, smoke, steam or boil with various cook settings; Electric BBQ grill's clearly marked control knob makes it easy to access searing, steaming, smoking, and warming modes
- Grill From Frozen: Steam system thaws frozen foods, like steak and chicken, while your grill preheats; When it's ready, sear on the grilling side for easy weeknight meals
- Keep Warm: Keep your food warm until it's ready to serve, then open the outdoor grill's lid for buffet-style self-service; Low-dome lid design helps cook flatter foods, like steak and fish, efficiently
- Easy Cleaning: Green electric grill has a front-access grease tray that makes removal and clean-up a breeze, allowing you to focus on grilling instead of cleaning
5. Cleaning access
Cleaning should influence the purchase, not just the maintenance routine. The Popular Mechanics review specifically identifies the area beneath the Lumin’s heating element as difficult to clean. The Q 1400’s removable catch pan is a useful design detail. For any model, check which parts are removable, where grease collects, and whether the manual specifies a particular cleaning method before using abrasive tools or chemicals.
Electric grills versus charcoal and gas
An electric grill can solve a practical fuel and placement problem: it does not require a propane cylinder or charcoal bed, and the Lumin’s documented versatility works without an open-flame fuel source. That does not make all electric grills equivalent to charcoal or gas.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Charcoal remains the more natural choice for someone who considers charcoal flavor and live-fire cooking essential. The Lumin and Ninja can provide smoke-related flavor, but the evidence here does not support claiming that either produces the same flavor profile as charcoal. Gas grills may also offer a different balance of heat, capacity, and cooking workflow. Choose electric because its power source, size, and permitted-use profile fit your location—not because it is automatically a one-for-one replacement for every other grill type.
Pre-purchase checklist
- Confirm that the exact model is permitted at your apartment, condominium, rental, balcony, deck, or HOA property.
- Measure the cooking location, storage area, lid clearance, stand footprint, and cord route.
- Check the outlet type and the model’s wattage or voltage requirements.
- Decide whether you need only grilling or would genuinely use smoking, steaming, griddling, air frying, roasting, or dehydrating.
- Compare cooking area separately from manufacturer serving claims.
- Check cleaning access, particularly around the heating element and grease collection area.
- Verify current price, retailer stock, warranty terms, model number, and accessory compatibility.
- For the Cuisinart CEG-980, recheck availability because the official page showed it out of stock during research.
Sources and attribution
Independent performance context comes from Popular Mechanics’ tested electric-grill guide and hands-on Weber Lumin review, Forbes Vetted’s electric-grill roundup, and Good Housekeeping’s indoor-grill testing coverage. Current product specifications and accessory or replacement-part information come from the official Weber, Ninja, Cuisinart, and George Foreman product materials. Manufacturer capacity figures are labeled as such, and the exact George Foreman model tested by Good Housekeeping is distinguished from the GFO201R-TX listed here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which electric grill is best overall?
The Weber Lumin Electric Grill is the best overall pick because Popular Mechanics selected it as the best electric grill in a current tested guide and its hands-on review found quick heating, good heat retention with the lid closed, and useful smoking, steaming, warming, and griddle-style capabilities. It is not the best choice for everyone: the cooking area is limited, it loses temperature more readily with the lid open, and cleaning beneath the heating element is difficult.
Which electric grill has the most cooking functions?
The Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL has the widest range of functions. Ninja lists grilling, BBQ smoking, air frying, roasting, baking, broiling, and dehydrating, along with app-based monitoring and control, two built-in thermometers, and real wood pellets for smoke flavor.
Are electric grills allowed on balconies?
Not necessarily. Electric operation does not automatically make a grill legal on every balcony, deck, or shared outdoor area. Check your building, HOA, rental, and local rules, then follow the appliance manual and confirm the outlet requirements for the exact model.
Is the Cuisinart CEG-980 available?
The official Cuisinart product page showed the CEG-980 as out of stock at the time of research. Because inventory changes, check Cuisinart and live retailer listings immediately before buying.
Is the George Foreman GFO201R-TX the same model tested by Good Housekeeping?
No. Good Housekeeping’s George Foreman value pick came from testing a smaller indoor contact grill. The GFO201R-TX in this comparison is a separate 200-square-inch rectangular indoor/outdoor model, so the test result should not be treated as a direct review of it.
The Bottom Line
Bottom line: Buy the Weber Lumin for the best documented all-around electric-grill experience, the Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL for maximum versatility, or the Weber Q 1400 for a simpler traditional balcony grill. Consider the Cuisinart CEG-980 only after confirming it is back in stock, and choose the George Foreman GFO201R-TX when large, uncomplicated indoor/outdoor cooking matters most.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
