A gas BBQ is worth considering if you grill often and want quick starts, simple heat control and less hands-on setup. If smoky flavor and arranging coals are central to the experience you want, charcoal may suit you better. There is no universal winner: the value depends on how you cook, what you enjoy and the costs where you live.
When a gas BBQ is worth it
Gas grills are typically more convenient than charcoal grills because you can start cooking by turning on the burners, according to Consumer Reports’ grill buying guide. That convenience can matter most for frequent weeknight meals, when you want to get cooking without managing a bed of coals.
Gas also offers straightforward heat control through the burners. If you value a predictable, relatively simple routine more than tending the fire, those advantages may justify the purchase. They do not, by themselves, establish that gas costs less over the grill’s lifetime.
When charcoal may be a better fit
Choose charcoal if you enjoy the smoky character and the more hands-on process of cooking over coals. Consumer Reports’ grill team puts the distinction this way: “gas is great for quicker weeknight cooking, and charcoal provides the ultimate in flexibility because you control the heat based on how you arrange the coals.” Consumer Reports’ grilling article
Recommended Free Tools
#1 Best Overall
- JUICIER RESULTS: Our patented Amplifire cooking system produces the best-tasting food with 50% juicier results, while on-the-go.
- ON-THE-GO DESIGN: Secure grill with stainless steel latches and transport with easy-to-grip handles.
- COOKING AREA: Cook up to 8 burgers at a time with 200-square-inches of cooking space.
- DURABLE MATERIAL: Built to last with cast-aluminum firebox and lid, plus a high-impact frame.
- EASY-START IGNITION: Enjoy a convenient, reliable, and smooth start with a push of a button.
Flavor is a preference, not a reliable reason to declare one fuel best for everyone. If you have no strong preference, Consumer Reports recommends weighing ease of use, cost and construction rather than relying on taste claims alone.
Compare the costs, not just the sticker price
Budget for the grill itself as well as recurring fuel and maintenance. Consumer Reports’ 2025 U.S. buying guide says some larger, feature-packed grills cost more than $3,000, while it is possible to find a top-performing option in its ratings for under $500. These are broad examples, not live prices or guarantees for every market or budget.
Rank #2
- COOKING SYSTEM: With the power of liquid propane this Portable Gas Grill is convenient and versatile
- GRATES: Durable porcelain coated grates for rust-resistance and easy-to-clean convenience
- SIZE: 190 square inches of cooking space Dimensions: 15" H x 24.1" W x 12.3" D
- DURABLE: Steel construction and a durable, high-temperature finish help prevent rust to extend the life of the grill
- WARRANTY: 90 Days Burner, Grate, Lid and Other Parts
There is no established universal fuel-cost break-even point for gas versus charcoal. What you spend depends on local fuel prices, how often you cook, the quality and service life of the grills being compared, and upkeep. Compare models and local fuel costs that fit your own use rather than relying on a generic payback calculation.
Use these questions to choose
- How often will you grill? Frequent, quick meals make gas’s easy start more valuable; occasional cooking may not justify paying extra for convenience.
- Which cooking experience do you want? Favor gas for burner-based heat control and a simpler routine; favor charcoal if arranging coals and smoky character are part of the appeal.
- What fits your budget? Include purchase price, fuel and maintenance, not just the initial cost.
- Do you have the right space and fuel? Check that the grill and its fuel suit your outdoor setup and any applicable local requirements.
- Is the grill well constructed? If taste does not decide the choice, compare construction and ease of use alongside cost.
Keep a gas grill safe and maintained
Use a gas grill outdoors and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for setup, operation and inspection. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission’s May 20, 1997 release advises: “Check grill hoses for cracking, brittleness, holes, and leaks.” It also recommends checking for blocked burner tubes. Follow your grill’s instructions for these checks and for addressing any suspected leak or blockage; do not use a damaged grill until it has been dealt with safely.
Rank #3
- 【DURABLE STEEL CONSTRUCTION】Built with a heat-resistant finish, the tabletop grill's sturdy steel frame provides long-lasting protection against wear and tear while maintaining aesthetic appeal
- 【STAINLESS STEEL BURNER】Offering a total of 11,000 BTUs from its high-powered burner, the camping grill delivers reliable and consistent heat, allowing for efficient grilling of all your favorite foods.
- 【360 SQ IN COOKING SPACE】Versatile cooking space provides ample space for grilling a variety of food at once, the portable propane grill is ideal for BBQs, patio, and garden gatherings
- 【EASY SETUP & STORAGE】Thanks to its foldable legs and locking lid, this portable bbq grill offers enhanced portability and simple storage without compromising on stability during use.
- 【FAST & EFFICIENT HEATING】The portable grill features high-power burners and a porcelain steel firebox, reaching high temperatures quickly for fast cooking and delicious grilled meals on the go
The same 1997 CPSC release reported about 30 people injured annually in gas grill fires and explosions. That is a historical figure from the release, not a current annual injury rate. Read the CPSC release.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- QUICK & EASY SETUP: The Cuisinart Chef's Style Tabletop Portable Propane Grill gets you grilling in less than 10 minutes. This outdoor grill is designed for a fast, hassle-free setup—no tools required.
- POWERFUL PORTABLE GRILL: This BBQ grill features two powerful stainless steel burners, each with 10,000 BTU of heat. With electronic ignition and independent control knobs, this tabletop grill lets you create custom heat zones for different foods.
- STAINLESS STEEL GRATES: Experience the performance of a full-size barbeque grill in a compact form. The stainless steel grates deliver even heat distribution, making it the perfect camping grill for large cuts of meat or delicate foods.
- LIGHTWEIGHT & PORTABLE: Weighing only 22 lb., this portable grill is easy to carry and transport. The locking lid, folding legs, and convenient carry handle make this outdoor grill the ideal choice for camping trips, tailgating, or backyard BBQs.
- PRECISE HEAT CONTROL: The integrated thermometer and adjustable burner knobs of the Cuisinart grill give you complete control over the portable gas grill's temperature. Enjoy reliable ignition every time with the twist-start automatic ignition.
Rank #4
- 【STAINLESS STEEL CONSTRUCTION】Built with heat and rust-resistant stainless steel, the tabletop grill is designed to withstand harsh weather conditions and maintain its durability over time.
- 【2-BURNER DESIGN】Offering a total of 16,000 BTUs from its two burners, the camping grill delivers reliable and consistent heat, allowing for efficient grilling of all your favorite foods.
- 【EASY SETUP & STORAGE】Thanks to its foldable legs and locking lid, this portable bbq grill offers enhanced portability and simple storage without compromising on stability during use.
- 【VERSATILE COOKING SPACE】199 square inches of cooking space provides ample space for grilling a variety of food at once, the portable propane grill is ideal for BBQs, patio, and garden gatherings
- 【STAINLESS STEEL COOKING GRID】Crafted from stainless steel, the table top grill's cooking grid ensures optimal heat retention and even distribution, resulting in evenly cooked meals every time.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
